Race fans often talk about which drivers in the storied history of the Indianapolis 500 were the best. But how do you compare drivers from such different eras? Until the 1970s, the incredible danger of auto racing made for short careers. Few drivers made more than 10 starts. But starting with the late 1960s, careers expanded to 20 or more races. How do you compare Bill Vukovich, who won 2 races, and nearly won 4 in just a 5-year career, with A.J. Foyt who won 4 races in an incredible span of 35 races?
The real answer is that there is no way to objectively make the comparison. But here's my own subjective compilation of the 33 best driver starting lineup.
Row 1: Rick Mears -- In 15 races, Mears won 4 times, took the pole position a record 6 times, and started on the front row 11 times -- all records. Simply the best
A.J. Foyt - the legend. 35 races, 4 wins, and more stories than anyone can count.
Al Unser, Sr. -- 4 time winner. He simply knew how to win the 500.
Row 2: Wilbur Shaw -- 3 time winner, & saved the 500 after World War II by convincing Tony Hulman to purchase the track. Until his death in a 1954 plane crash, it was Shaw who served as President of the Speedway and who each year started the race with command "Gentlemen, Start Your Engines", which was the title of his popular autobiography.
Bill Vukovich -- nearly won 4 consecutive races. Vukie crashed in 1952 on lap 192 when his steering broke. In 1953 he won and was only driver to complete the sweltering race without relief. Vukie dominated won in 1954. In 1955, Vukie was leading on lap 55 when a car spun into his path. His car catapulted over the wall, flipping end over end, and bursting into flames, fatally injuring Vukie.
Bobby Unser -- 3 time winner, and started on front row 9 times
Row 3: Johnny Rutherford -- 3 time winner
Louis Meyer -- first 3 time winner
Maurie Rose -- 3 time winner
Row 4: Helio Castroneves -- won his first 2 500s, only driver to do so. Finished second in his third race, coming within one position of winning three consecutive 500s, a feat no one has accomplished
Mario Andretti -- A victim of so many bad luck days, that the phrase "Mario is slowing down" became part of the Speedway lexicon. Mario won only 1 500, but finished second to Danny Sullivan's "spin and win", and was 2d, then declared winner, then finally returned to 2d in the controversial 1981 finish with Bobby Unser that took nearly a year of legal wrangling to finally decide.
Emerson Fittipaldi -- 2 time winner, including wheel to wheel duel with Al Unser Sr. Would have had 3 wins if not for late race crash while leading by nearly a lap.
Row 5: Jim Clark -- In his short Indy career, 2-time world champion Jim Clark ignited the rear-engine revolution when he finished 2d his rookie run in 1963. He followed with a win in 1965 and another 2d place in 1966, although car owner Andy Granitelli maintained there was a scoring error and that Clark won that race, too.
Ralph DePalma -- Known most for the race he didn't win, the 1912 race where he led 196 laps, before breaking down on lap 198. DePalma and his mechanic created an Indy legend when they pushed their disabled car down the main straight. But DePalma did win in 1915, and nearly a century after he raced, he still appears in the Top 10 list for most laps lead in the 500.
Al Unser, Jr.-- Two time winner, winning the closest race in Indianapolis 500 history over Scott Goodyear, and losing out in a wheel to wheel duel with Emerson Fittipaldi.
Row 6: Roger Ward -- 2 time winner and a class act. Always wore white dinner jacket to Awards Banquet, where in 1966 he announced, "I promised myself that when racing wasn't fun anymore, I'd retire. Yesterday, it wasn't fun."
Tommy Milton -- First 2-time Indy winner
Gordon Johncock -- Winner of the rain-delayed crash-marred1973 race that no one wanted to remember, Johncock got his due in 1982 when he won the race no one could forget, out-dueling Rick Mears in perhaps the most exciting final 20 laps ever at the Speedway.
Row 7: Tom Sneva -- Winner, 3-time second place finisher, and broke the 200 mph barrier
Parnelli Jones: In a short Indy career, Jones won in 1963, and broke the 150 mph barrier in 1962. But he may be best remembered for the one that got away. In 1967 he drove the unique STP turbine car and dominated the 500, only to stop just 2 laps short when a small part failed, giving A.J. Foyt his 3d 500 win.
Ray Harroun -- He started it all. One race, one win -- and the invention of the rear view mirror for good measure.
Row 8: Arie Luyendyk -- The Flying Dutchman was popular and a 2-time winner
Jimmy Murphy -- The 1922 winner was an early race superstar who was successful in both the United States and Europe.
Jim Rathmann -- Finished 2d three times before winning in 1960 in one of the most exciting 2-car races in Speedway history. Over the last 80 laps of the race, Rathmann and Roger Ward exchanged the lead 14 times, not counting the times they passed and repassed so that the official leader at the end of the lap remained the same.
Row 9 Bill Holland -- The 1949 winner also finished 2d in 1948 and 1947. But he was leading in 1947 when confusion in hand signals caused him to ease up and let teammate Maurie Rose pass him. Otherwise, Holland would have had 2 wins.
Mark Donohue -- The 1972 winner started Roger Penske's success at the Speedway
Jimmy Bryan -- Cigar in mouth, the 1958 winner was a larger-than-life legend
Row 10: Sam Hanks -- 1957 winner (driving the car Bryan would drive in 1958) won then promply retired in Victory Lane, the only driver ever to do so.
Jules Goux -- Drank 6 pints of wine during the course of the race and won by the widest margin ever, over 13 minutes -- REALLY
Michael Andretti -- Inherited family's bad luck. In Indy's top 10 list for laps competed, laps lead, and prize money -- the only non-winner on any of those lists
Row 11: Billy Arnold -- Arnold's 1930 win was the most dominent performance in 500 history, leading 198 laps.
Rex Mays -- Never a win, but 4 poles (a record until Mears), and led 9 races at a time when cars did not bunch up under the yellow. Deprived of 4 years during the peak of his racing career while the track was closed for WWII, Mays was among the best of his time.
Ted Horn -- Most consistent driver ever at the Speedway. After his rookie year, Horn competed in 9 500s, and never finished lower than 4th. He too was deprived of four prime racing years during WWII.